Top 12 Male


First let me just say, I hate plants, I hate David A., Michael Johns already. If we could get rid of them, and Kristy Lee Cook & Carly whatever, I'll be so happy. But that's never gonna happen, even in my dreams. And this is your gayest Top 12 guys~

David Hernandez, who looks a bit like Seinfeld, I guess? He's okey, seems sweet. It's decent. I'm not amused.

Chikieze, who has no last name, is really bad, he couldn't find the pitch at the beginning. The talkback is stupid.

David Cook, this is one of my fave song, I flove it!!! The arrangement is good, although meaningless, I still like it~~~

Jason Yeager, Moonriver? The hell? That was..I'm speechless. Farewell, you'll be Nicked.

Robbie Carrico, I hate this 1,2 song!!!!!! 2 is lonely too? Writer, you must love threesome, don't cha?

David A., I didn't realize the band was so loud until he came up. He's decent, but doesn't live up to all that pimping. And his voice cracked a little bit. I don't like his "innocence", as a 17, Garrett Haley can be innocent, coz he has no experience, and it shows! You, dude, who won Star Search, should stop the "WOW I DIDN'T KNOW YOU WOULD LIKE ME" thing.

Danny Noriega, "Jack 2008". Love the skinny black tie, I have one~That'a very...Taylor Hicks...-_-|||, if close my eyes, he's not bad~The "liking it" was so funny!

Luke Menard, he's so boring, even his audition was boring as hell. Love the guitar in background. BORING. Bye bye~

Colton Berry, I hate his hair... The singing is okey~

Garrett Haley, looks like a pretty little girl...is borting as well, whatever.

Jason Castro, horrible hair...dude...I like drummers too~~~The song is just lovely~ The performance feels like it could be his own song~Love it~I don't know how he'll do when he's without the guitar.

Michael Johns, this is why I don't like him, I think he's a bad person. I mean, as a person, he's bad, angry, fake...like that, I just feel he is. The singing is okey~ Let's face it, all rockers on Idol are fakers, rockers don't come to idol. Amanda( the nurse) could stay on Rockstar around about top 8, Michael Johns would get cut much earlier, David Cook, Robbie Carrico wouldn't pass the audition.

Out: Jason Yeager, Luke Menard


Top 12 Female


Before the show starts, I like Alexandrea Lushington & Ramiele Malubay already, cos they both love Jason Mraz, who, imo, is the best singer/songwriter in the universe.

Kristy Lee Cook, the dull hot girl. The thing she does with her face & eyes is a bit scary, other than that, she's totally boring.

JoAnne Borgella. Her voice bugs me, it's so thin, low or high, it's annoying. I hope she can go ASAP.

Alaina Whitaker, Carrie Underwood's fun sister. It's uptempo & fun, I don't like country at all, but it's nice~

Amanda Overmyer, this girl is fierce~The lack of melody & scatting are not so good, but that's not a big problem, she's so unique in this bunch. The hair, I hate...

Amy Davis, I think she looks like Teri Hatcher, well, this is totally hideous...The boys are out there, go get'em, just never sing to them...

Brooke White, she is so nervous, her voice just shakes and shakes. The vibe is nice~ I'm not sure how she can do.

Alexandrea Lushington, who lost to David A. in Star Search. I like her Hollywood singing! This song, on the other hand, is so blah...whatever, see what comes up next week.

Kady Malloy, I love her Britney!!! The beginning of the song is really nice, then it gets really boring. I hope she doesn't go so we can see more.

Asia'h Epperson, that's really nice & fun, but I want her out. It just feels like she could lose her voice any minute.

Ramiele Malubay, this girl has got some brain, she may be the smartest of this bunch. She chooses such a dramatic song to make a impression on her first night, so over the top it's not boring. Not perfect, the low notes aren't deep enough, the high ones aren't all there, but it's good enough to make her a spot in top 12. I'm surprised Simon likes it though, shouldn't he be feeling it's too theatric? Maybe other girls sucked too much.

Syesha Mercado, well, she feels like lose her voice any minute too. The shouting at the end is not necessary.

Carly Smithson, oh, the tool. She was supposed to be MCA's answer to Britney, man, even these days, she's not as attractive as Britney. (Billie Piper, who plays in Doctor Who, was UK's answer to Britney, she's big fun!) I don't know the song, to my somehow tone-deaf ears, she couldn't find a lot of the low notes. Randy is just so shameless.

Overall, Idol is so boring compared to Dance.

Out: Amy Davis and whoever.


Top 10 Male


 Michael Johns, god it's so awful I laugh out loud. This is just...wrong song or wrong key. So funny.

Jason Castro, the interview is charming! I know this song, but totally didn't recognize it, that's really good. It's nice enough. He's so my genre, but I don't think you can get more than nice from him, how? Big notes don't happen in folk...

Luke Menard, HongKong? Nice~The Bohemian Rhapsody part was okey. But this performance, is so funny. The high notes are funny. Overall, funny in a bad way, very...half-human.

Robbie Carrico. The hair is just... He has too much hair to shave his head, but...at least do something with it, please. Take a shower, dude. The singing, I totally don't care. I hope he can pack his ass ASAP.

Danny Noriega, man, I totally love this song, when Sonic Youth covers it! Danny is no Sonic Youth, apparently, he's not even Ruben. This is boring and decent. Decent is not enough for this drama queen.

David Hernandez, who is the cutest guy there in my eyes, great smile, and yeah...I know he's gay and was a gay stripper, good for him. Do they want an all-gay season? Or Ryan manipulated this? The last note is unnecessary, but overall, it's totally not boring.

Jason Yager, why is he still here??? I can't get over the yellow hair, and the necklace. That's some gay pride performance... Farewell, again.

Chikieze, that's nice, I guess? Totally don't care. The "only you do that" is really funny. XD

David Cook, OMG, I love word-nerds!!! Reminds me of Gus from Psych! I find spelling so sexy, seriously, coz I can't spell. Out of all these fake rockers, I like him the best, maybe because of his tone, something about it I really like. It's a shame he looks like the guy from School of Rock. BTW Richard Linklater is an amazing director.

David Archuleta, the pimping, god...But to be honestly, I think this is one of best performances idol ever had, I like quiet, peaceful performances. I don't like his tone though. "Don't leaving me?", is he flirting with Ryan?

Out: Jason Yager, Luke Menard. Please, please, please.


Top 10 Female

So, Robbie was really wearing a wig, so so so funny. Very rock, dude!

Now I see why back to season 2 people hated Clay. David A. is totally like him. All the girls loved him, voted, and he sang boring ballads with big notes week after week, and JUST WOULDN‘T GO. If I didn't know his fun personality first I'd hate season 2. But way back then, this show had its innocence. All the talents just walked right off street. Take Carmen, who was horrible on thow, sometimes she was okey, sometimes it took her a whole song to find a key. Now she's just a good country & jazz singer. Nothing is better than after Kurt Nilsen auditioned, judges saying,  now label has signed many ugly singer, but he's just too ugly to ever get signed, who, turned out to be one of the best singers alive.

Carly, okey, boring, a bit strained. "I don't think any of these girls can touch you vocally?" Really? Why don't you just tell us whom should we vote for, Simon?

Syesha, just okey, better than many other girls tonight. Quentin from Star Academy did much much better with it.

Brooke White, never heard of Carly Simon...I love folk, but don't like her at all. She looks a bit maniac, and doesn't have the subdued voice for folk. That's totally a ballad under a folk cover, and not well sung.

Ramiele, disco? Really? Disco? Do you know what happened to Storm Large when she sang I Will Survive? Well she probably doesn't know who that is. I hate disco with a passion. This is slightly worse than meh.

Kristy Lee Cook, tomboy != standing strangely on stage. Meh, whatever.

Amanda, the hair...THE HAIR! I have a feeling this is really a lovely song, but she just can't deliver. So, I'm over her. Go or stay, whatever. But for my eyes' sake, I hope she'll go. God, the hair! They were capable of  making it worse!!! Idol people are talented! Way too much melody? Sorry, I accidentally like melody, any singer can't deliver it is not a good one in my universe.

Alaina, weird no food touching girl. I truely love this song. Her singing...not much. It's okey I guess. Emotionless.

Alex, boring, meh. Secretly, I'm a racist, cos I don't like R&B, at all.

Kady, I wish she could add a bit opera to her songs! That would very Jason Mraz! Does this song has some weird minor key, or it takes her a whole song to find the key, and failing? Ugly shirt BTW.

Asia'H, who should never sing a Celine song. The lost By is so unforgettable. I remember when I heard it on Dirty Sexy Money, was so funny! And somehow sincere. She's...almost like Jeremy, just not as sincere.

Out: Amanda, Kady.


Top 8 Male

I love it, cause my faves have done good~Hoho

Clay is gonna have a new album out in the summer. I'm so over him now, but I'm still glad. Finally, he goes into a genre I'm remotely interested in and found a producer (who produced Sting) to do a whole cd. And, the probable title track is writen by Ryan Tedder of One Republic. And the best song ever Lover All Alone is gonna be put on track. And, there's a song has some R&B vibe, a little like James Morrison. Are you kidding me? Does any thing I listen to just always finally go to James Morrison now? Well...I've past my Claymate days...maybe...

The same goes for David A. With his voice, he can go r&b, but the sex appeal is just not there, at all! Or, he can do AC like Josh Groban...which would be totally boring. Whatever on that, he'll do boring ballads through this season, ugh.

Luke, bad, gone, please. Last week, Queen. This week, Wham! Isn't he trying to come out?

David A., lord of ringers. The piano is a nice touch, as piano being of my 2 fave instruments with cello. And...boring. The world-saving answer is unbelievable.

Danny, not as entertaining as usual. I've always wished he could rip a song! But it's just not happening...

David H., oh so entertaining! If I have to listen to boring ballads, I'd prefer him to David A. anytime. The pitch, is nowhere to be found though.

Michael Johns...he's pretty Constantine to me, the mic-up-in-the-air gesture and all, except I actually like Constantine. Con is an ass, but he had some theatre experience, and did the best he could with his not-so-good voice. Michael just...sounds bad and lazy. Soul rock...I hate it.

David Cook, oh, I find him a bit attractive, god, help me. Love it, that's all. Simon is so nice.

Jason! Apparently, weeds has damaged part of his brain, but the song choice has been amazing! This may be one of the worst versions of Hallelujah I've heard, but I still love it.

Chikezie. Weirdly, I love big songs with a bit r&b twist on them. So I totally love it. But he auditioned with it? So no wonder it's good.

Out, I only hope: Luke and...Michael Johns, or Danny. But David H. and Chikezie are more possible.


Top 8 Female太差了竟然没有写


Top 12


So, Lennon and McCartney, a list of 25 song to choose from? Are you kidding me? How many songs have Beatles written? Thousands? This show is so cheap and manipulative.

The new stage is so UFO.

Syesha. WTH is that? The "belting" is so so so...weird. Whatever.

Chikezie. He is somehow likeable tonight. Nice, good, great. Very believable. It's like a great performance at a great club. (I mean it in a good way, best performances always happen in clubs.)

Ramiella, my very fave Beatles song(cause Storm Large sang it...) Hate, wrong register makes it so fake. Hate. Kill her.

God, how much money did iTunes give Idol...

Jason, so they'll always allow instruments? Good. It's...nice. I can see why he chose this, originally it's very guitar-heavy. Now I know whom he reminds me of! Landon Pigg! I can't accept the fact he's 2 years younger than me...

Carly, oh how much I hate her. I don't think I've ever hated a contestant like this before, just indifferent at most. Everytime she does an interview, I hate her some more. She thinks she deserves this more than half of them there? God! It's based on talent, gal, not how many 300-selling albums you've done. People say this performance is good? I totally don't care.

WTF is Ryan doing?

David C., my beloved one. Oh...hate the jacket. The verse is really not good at all. Why does Simon praise him like that?

Brooke, less cracks in her voice tonight, pretty enjoyable, still not great.

David H, oh, pink shirt. The end.

Amanda, hate the pants, the hair is okey for the first time. The singing is very whatever.

Micheal, he was a football player, I love football (actually I only love Friday Night Lights) and majored in drama, it's like I'm supposed to like him, but I don't. Love the verse, hate the chorus. And I HATE anyone who wears a tee inside a suit!!!!

Kristy, huh?

David A., who cried in the intro, way to make me hate him. I think he's worse than Kristy. But it's so hard to be happy...He'll get more votes!!! God!!!

Out: Kristy or Syesha.


Top 11


So, Beatles again. After thinking about it, it's not that bad, better than hearing the songs that have been sung on Idol 20 times before. It's understandable because last week was the first time the rating got better than last season. It's all about who wouldn't make the tour this week. Songs I want to hear: Hey Jude & Here There Everywhere, which nobody will do, well... About the themes, just one wish: No DISCO!

Amanda, I love her when she's not singing. As always, too many off notes. But still likeable. "Ballads are boring." How can you not love her.

Kristy, she's so hot. Well...just no.

David Archuleta, wow, he's able to find this song from Beatles? Boring as can be. Master class? Compared to last week, yeah. But I've pretty got over the pimping. Everything is skippable.

And I guess no one wonder why don't I like Apple now, cool it is not.

Michael, who should never wear a hat again. Once again, like the beginning, then it goes all the way down. However, secretly, he's growing on me. So awkward on stage it's adorable. But this is so not going to carry him on.

Brooke, not good. Is she drunk? Why is she talking so much?

David Cook, my beloved one. Very relaxed, methinks it's better than last week, if not a bit boring. Why wouldn't Ryan try the "vox"?! It's so funny he credited...Whitesnakes? Somebody has been reading the forums.

Carly, whom I totally don't care about.

Jason, stoned, he's...so...talking about the bad note? Oh I hate french. It's very Jason.

Syesha, "half that girl"? The lyrics changing bugs the hell out of me. But I love this. So believable. I thought it would be oversung, maybe it is. Still I bought it.

What is Ryan doing to that senior citizen?

Chikezie, nice, I personally feel it's a bit off-beat, weird. Poor guy has to do so much more than anyone to stay here.

Ramiele, who should have known better than doing this song.

Out: I don't know! It's a mistery!